Look and feel: These are the only wipes we tested that have a quilted texture—and they’re clothlike, big (7.1 in x 8 in), and extra thick. The large dispenser is a breeze to open, but it can still be tricky to pull just a single wipe.
Effectiveness: The packaging’s claim of a gentle and durable product is, well, an honest one. These wipes amply do their duty in messy diaper situations.
Ingredients: While the others we tested are all a mere 99% water, these one-up the competition with—wait for it—OVER 99% water. They’re also plant-based, enlisting ingredients like cucumber, licorice root, and flower extracts. Though they’re fragrance-free, the aforementioned ingredients impart a subtle botanical scent.
Price: from $0.06/count (Amazon)
